Armenia Loses Voting Rights in Russia-led CSTO

| News, Security, Armenia

The Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) has Armenia of its voting rights and its right to nominate representatives for senior positions within the organisation following a decision adopted at its Collective Security Council meeting in Moscow on 11 November. Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov confirmed that the member states had approved the measure under Article 25 of the CSTO Charter, citing Armenia's failure to fulfil its financial obligations and pay membership contributions for more than two years. The restrictions will remain in force until Armenia settles its outstanding payments. Armenia did not participate in the CSTO ministerial meetings in Moscow on 10 November.

CSTO Secretary General Taalatbek Masadykov subsequently that the organisation had not discussed Armenia's expulsion and that the country could restore its full participation once its membership fees were paid. This would include the restoration of voting rights, the right to nominate representatives and the ability to send personnel to the CSTO Secretariat and Joint Staff. As Masadykov noted, Armenia had neither paid its membership contributions nor seconded personnel to the organisation's structures during the preceding three years. Although Armenian representatives had technically remained present at Permanent Council meetings, they had not participated in discussions or contributed to the organisation's work. Russian officials, including Lavrov and Peskov, emphasised that the decision did not terminate Armenia's membership or its right to collective security under the treaty.

The decision prompted from Armenian officials. Security Council Secretary Alen Simonyan with a poem in a post in Russian, writing: "They stripped us of our voice right there, where everyone was loudly silent as they killed us, all in unison." Russian Foreign Ministry spokesperson Maria Zakharova, in turn, with sarcasm that the poem actually had a fourth line. The last line goes:  “Simonyan made up the tale” ’, Zakharova added. In response, Simonyan another poem in Russian. One of the poem's references to ‘Simonyan’ was directed at Margarita Simonyan, a well-known Kremlin spox of Armenian origin who frequently criticises Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s government.

National Assembly Speaker Ruben Rubinyan also rejected Russian officials' arguments that Armenia's dissatisfaction with the CSTO stemmed from the organisation's failure to intervene in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict. According to Rubinyan, Armenia had never appealed to the CSTO over Karabakh but had requested assistance when Azerbaijani forces attacked its internationally recognised sovereign territory in the Gegharkunik, Vayots Dzor and Syunik regions in 2021 and 2022. In Rubinyan's view, Armenia expected the organisation to fulfil its treaty obligations towards a member state facing an attack on its territory, but the CSTO failed to act.

Russian Federation Council Speaker Valentina Matviyenko Armenia's complaints against the CSTO as unfounded, describing them as an attempt to shift responsibility for Nagorno-Karabakh onto Russia and the organisation. Speaking to journalists in Hanoi on 12 November, she stressed that the CSTO had acted strictly in accordance with its statutory documents during the conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan. Matviyenko reiterated that the decision to remain in or withdraw from the organisation was Armenia's sovereign right, but warned that Yerevan would "lose a lot" if it left. Matviyenko also argued that Armenia could not simultaneously pursue EU membership and maintain its EAEU membership, as the two integration frameworks were incompatible and would eventually require a choice by the Armenian people. At the same time, she maintained that any decision by Armenia would not undermine the overall stability of the EAEU, which she described as an effective and mutually beneficial organisation.

Belarusian Foreign Minister Maxim Ryzhenkov adopted a tougher position, restrictions on Armenia's access to classified CSTO documents. In an interview, he questioned whether Yerevan should retain full access to confidential information and described Armenia as a "false ally". Ryzhenkov claimed that sensitive information could potentially be used against the interests of other CSTO members and accused the Armenian authorities of seeking to benefit selectively from membership in the organisation and the EAEU without fulfilling their obligations. Ryzhenkov specifically referred to Armenia's continued access to preferential energy prices and trade and transport benefits. His proposal concerned potential restrictions on classified information and had not been announced as an adopted CSTO decision.

Within Armenia, the decision from the ruling party and the opposition. Sargis Khandanyan, a ruling Civil Contract MP and chairman of the National Assembly's Foreign Relations Committee, said the restrictions would not significantly change the existing situation because Armenia had already frozen its participation and did not intend to resume activities within the organisation. Khandanyan noted that Yerevan would approach the decision with understanding and that no immediate decision to formally withdraw was necessary. Another ruling party MP, Sona Ghazaryan, similarly stated that Armenia could wait another year or two, but insisted that the CSTO had exhausted its usefulness and that its position towards regional states was unacceptable.

Opposition representatives, however, questioned the government's broader security policy and the absence of a clearly defined alternative. Artur Khachatryan, an MP from the Armenian parliamentary faction, argued that Armenia could not confront regional security challenges alone and criticised the government's pursuit of a non-aligned foreign policy. While acknowledging serious shortcomings in the CSTO's response to Azerbaijan's actions in 2021-2022 and the Russian peacekeeping mission in Nagorno-Karabakh, he cautioned that losing an existing ally did not automatically mean that new security partners would emerge. Narek Karapetyan of the Strong Armenia parliamentary faction also called on the government to present a credible alternative to the existing security arrangements. Stepan Danielyan, a member of the extra-parliamentary Mother Armenia movement, described the CSTO decision as largely symbolic, saying that Armenia's leadership had already effectively deprived itself of influence within the organisation.

Separately, Russian Foreign Ministry spokesperson Maria Zakharova at the request of foreign states. She stated that five Russian citizens had been detained in Armenia since the beginning of 2026 following relevant requests from other countries. Zakharova alleged that the charges brought against those detained often had little connection to reality and described the wider situation as part of what she called a campaign by Western countries against Russian citizens abroad. Her remarks added another point of tension to bilateral relations, particularly concerning the treatment of Russian nationals and cooperation between the two countries' law-enforcement and judicial authorities.

Addressing Armenia’s relations with Russia directly, Pashinyan that Armenia’s efforts to diversify its foreign policy and deepen relations with the European Union were not directed against Russia. Speaking at the Institute of International and European Affairs in Dublin on 14 November, he announced three planned visits to Russia in December, scheduled for 3, 11 and 22 December, for talks with Russian counterparts. “Our goal is not to undermine our relations with Russia. We do not want to create problems for Russia,” he said, expressing hope that both countries would maintain a friendly atmosphere in their bilateral relations. Pashinyan stressed that closer relations with the EU should not come at the expense of Armenia’s ties with Moscow.

See Also

"Caucasus Watch" seeks local specialists from Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan and the North Caucasus region. We offer a flexible format of cooperation, competitive remuneration and access to a European readership. Send CV, cover letter and writing sample to redaktion@caucasuswatch.de. Questions: i.dostalik@caucasuswatch.de

Our website uses cookies. By clicking on "I accept cookies", you consent to our use of cookies in accordance with the terms of our Cookie Policy. If you want to disable cookies follow the instructions in our Cookie Policy so that cookies from this website cannot be placed on your device.